Why Real Cocoa Matters
Share
Something is changing in the chocolate industry, and most people haven't heard about it yet. Some of the biggest names in chocolate are now backing cocoa grown in a laboratory. Cells are taken from cocoa beans and grown in steel tanks called bioreactors, then turned into cocoa powder and cocoa butter without a single cocoa tree. Mondelēz, the owner of Cadbury, is working with Celleste Bio, Cargill with Kokomodo, and Lindt has invested in Food Brewer. In the US, Puratos plans to sell chocolate made with lab-grown cocoa from California Cultured to bakers and chocolatiers by the end of 2026.
Their reasons are real. Climate change and disease are hitting harvests, and cocoa prices hit record highs over the last two years. We understand why they're looking for answers. But at Hill St., we find this rush towards synthetic cocoa disappointing, because chocolate is a crop and people grow it.
What happens to the farmers?
Lab-grown chocolate is often marketed as the more ethical or climate-friendly choice. Yet taking farms out of the supply chain does nothing for the people who grow cocoa today.
Between five and six million farmers grow the world's cocoa, most of them on small family plots (International Cocoa Organization). For whole villages in West Africa, Latin America and Asia, cocoa is the main income, and many of those farmers already struggle to earn a living from it.
Moving production into a laboratory won't fix low pay. It takes away the main income of millions of farming families, when the same companies could be paying those farmers properly.
We know the people who grow our cocoa
We make our own chocolate from the bean at 7 Hill St. in Saffron Walden, roasting, winnowing, grinding, refining and conching it ourselves, so we know where every bean comes from. A few of the growers behind our bars:
- Tanzania. Kokoa Kamili buys wet cocoa straight from the pods of around 5,000 smallholder farms, and pays more than the farmers would get if they fermented and dried the beans themselves. In other words, the farmers are paid more for less work.
- Uganda. Our Semuliki Forest beans come through Latitude Trade Co, a certified B Corporation that pays cash at collection points within walking distance of the farms, along with a premium price, training, insurance and microfinance.
- Nicaragua. This is where our bean-to-bar story began. Our Nicalizo beans come from a network of around 1,200 smallholders in Jinotega, bought by Ingemann and fermented and dried at its own facility.
- Honduras. A cooperative of 52 cocoa growers beside Lago de Yojoa, which moved from growing corn, beans and rice to cocoa and now handles every step after the harvest itself.
- Mexico. At Agua Escondida, farmer Malaquías grows cacao under a canopy of shade trees, alongside farms run by his relatives and neighbours.
If lab-grown cocoa takes off, it's growers like these who lose out. You can read more about each of them on our Bean to Bar Origins page.
Why real cocoa matters
There's flavour, too. Chocolate tastes of where it was grown, and of how carefully the beans were fermented and dried on the farm. You can taste it in our bars: apricot and mandarin in the Tanzania Kokoa Kamili 85%, sweet citrus and cinnamon in the Uganda Semuliki Forest 80%, grapes and raisins in the Nicaragua 64%. We don't think cocoa grown in a tank will taste of anywhere.
Is lab-grown chocolate real chocolate?
It starts from real cocoa cells, so in a technical sense it is cocoa, and the companies behind it say it looks, melts and tastes like the real thing. What it doesn't have is a farm behind it, or a farmer earning a living from it, and for us that's what matters.
Our commitment at Hill St.
We think the future of chocolate is with the farmers who grow it. For us, that means buying traceable cocoa from growers we can name, at prices that help them earn a proper living.
When you buy a Hill St. bar, you're supporting the farmers who grew the beans. We'd much rather buy from people we know than from a tank.